What Makes Some People Become Extraordinary?

What makes some people become extraordinary? There have always been child prodigies, but the majority of exceptional human beings are not born with a noticeable gift. Instead, they develop into outstanding achievers as they mature. The explanation for why they reach the creative heights seems to lie with self-alienation and psychological distress, a fact that for centuries has surrounded creativity with myths of wild inspiration and “divine” madness. Research has shown that exceptional individuals come more often from homes where there has been a lot of bickering and conflict.

Painting of the Muses Bringing Inspiration

Formerly, the Muses were thought to make people extraordinary. Nowadays we see inner bickering as the cause. (Image: public domain.)

Yet being troubled is not enough. The extraordinary person also possesses the ability to use that suffering to propel themselves down the long hard road of self-discovery and self-realization. It would seem that inner bickering and conflict are a necessary part of the creative process, leading one to speculate that creative people internalize the chaotic home life when they are children, and then exploit it as a resource when they become adults. When they are young, they raise their eyes from their embattled immediate surroundings. They look up to role models who seem to offer better ideas, better ways of looking at life, better and more interesting ways of living; they hero worship.

Those who will become extraordinary have released their drive to look for answers, to search for and know themselves. They are introspective and become embroiled in intellectual striving. They are, or become, spiritual, intellectual, and cultural pilgrims. In Jungian terms, they are developing and living out an archetypal behavior pattern. Hermann Hesse would say they are finding their inner destiny, not of their choosing, and living it out.

To borrow from Jung again, we can say that those who become extraordinary are those who have individuated, become true individuals, and developed all of their talents and capacities to the full. Perhaps the urge to individuate is a potential we all possess, but only a few (those exposed to the right conditions) ever realize. Distress activates the will to individuate, and individuation makes one extraordinary. The process of individuation carries within it the vital process of self-realization.

Self-realization is not self-improvement.

Self-realization is infinitely superior to self-improvement. This is so because self-realization focusses on revealing and enhancing one’s strengths while self-improvement is usually focussed on propping up or eliminating one’s weaknesses. To put it another way: self-realization is the achievable development of one’s actual capabilities, one’s genuine qualities, and one’s authentic character. Self-improvement is too often the futile attempt to put a shine on one’s already inaccurate false persona, one’s idealized self-image. The decision to self-improve is a manifestation of the refusal to accept oneself as one truly is. The obvious difficulty here is that one cannot work with what one has if one does not accept what one has. To engage in self-realization is to be loyal to one’s true self. To chase self-improvement is to be loyal to one’s false persona.

While most extraordinary individuals begin the individuation process early in life, it is possible to embark on the journey of self-discovery and self-realization later on. Two situations commonly launch the long-delayed individuation process: a life crisis that fatally challenges the false persona, or a nervous breakdown that collapses the idealized self-image entirely. In the first case, accepting the truth about oneself becomes unavoidable. The evidence that one is not what one would like to think has become impossible to deny. In the second, the eruption of repressed unconscious contents has swamped the psyche and everything is now out in the open where the restoration of sanity demands that one deal with it.

Author: Thomas Cotterill

I am a manic-depressive made philosophical by my long struggle with the disruptive mood disorder, during which I spent sixteen years living as a forest hermit. I write philosophical essays, fantasy, and science fiction. My attempt to integrate creativity, psychology, philosophy, and spirituality imbues everything I write. You will find hundreds of related essays and articles on my blog. I live quietly in British Columbia's scenic Fraser Valley, a beautiful place in which to wax philosophical.

7 thoughts on “What Makes Some People Become Extraordinary?”

  1. So many good quotes and take aways in this post!

    “Self-realization is infinitely superior to self-improvement.”

    And “it would seem that inner bickering and conflict are a necessary part of the creative process…”

    That last quote is a great comfort to me as I often wrestle with my creative process!

  2. Thanks for dropping by, Andrew. I think wrestling with the creative process is – in the long run – what makes creativity so interesting. In the short run, it can be extremely aggravating. Many creators are a bit like the German composer, Richard Strauss. He quarreled constantly with his wife. When asked why he stuck with her, he replied that he enjoyed quarreling!

  3. I don’t know Dabrowski’s theory, but a quick peek on Wikipedia reminds me of Jung’s idea of personality breakdown and re-integration along new lines during the individuation process (which most people never accomplish). It also reminds me of Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s new book *Antifragile*, which I plan to read soon. Keep these suggestions coming everydaybuckle, in this area, you are working a vein similar to my own.

Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: