The Creative Eureka Experience

One of the most commonly talked about aspects of the creative process is the phenomenon of having sudden key insights after one has carefully considered the facts and, unable to find a solution, turned to other things – the famous “eureka” experience. There are many entertaining anecdotes revealing how famous creators experienced a sudden flash of insight, often while doing something quite ordinary. Because of three particularly well-known stories, one might call this the bed, bath, and bus scenario.

Portrait of René Descartes by Jan Baptist Weenix

Rene Descartes had one of his greatest eureka moments while lying in bed idly watching a fly hover in the air. (Image: public domain.)

It all began in Greece. Archimedes supposedly had his eureka moment while relaxing in the public baths and ran home naked shouting “eureka” (I found it) thereby giving the experience its name. The bit about running au naturel through the streets is probably Roman hokum, but it does vividly capture the sense of intense excitement that accompanies the unexpected breakthrough. Henri Poincaré had his seminal insight into non-Euclidean geometry just as he boarded a bus. The idea seemed to come out of nowhere. The French mathematician attributed his insight to “unconscious work” and claimed an ability to ruminate on math problems while engaged in unrelated activities like chatting with a friend on a bus. Descartes suddenly envisioned his Cartesian co-ordinate system while lying in bed idly watching a fly hovering in the air. In all three cases, the insight followed considerable foundation-laying work that had as yet borne no fruit.

The best way to explain the eureka phenomenon is by considering how the human mind works. As we approach a problem, we make our first examination of the situation using the conscious reasoning faculty, which organizes and assesses the information logically. That is, we group or categorize all facts and the relationships among them according to the logic of the material. We consciously think about the problem. However, when the reasoning faculty cannot arrive at a suitable conclusion we reach an impasse. Life being what it is, we eventually have to let go and other activities occupy our attention. The faculty of memory takes over, storing our mental struggles, and as cognitive research has shown, memory is structured using feeling tone as the primary organizing principle. Memory does not use the logical grouping set up by the reasoning faculty. The brain reorganizes the material according to feeling-tone tags, a non-linear associative process that places bits of information in new juxtapositions. Finally, during one of these “distracted” periods, unexpected fresh insights, forged from those new juxtapositions or associations, suddenly break through into conscious awareness.

A further source of illumination may come from what was already in memory prior to tackling the problem. Some older memories will share the feeling tone of aspects of the problem at hand. As the brain files new material alongside these older memories, another set of non-linear juxtapositions or associations will be set up, this time with material that may have been previously unconsidered. Again, surprising insights may suddenly emerge while the conscious mind is preoccupied with unrelated activities.

Author: Thomas Cotterill

I am a manic-depressive made philosophical by my long struggle with the disruptive mood disorder, during which I spent sixteen years living as a forest hermit. I write philosophical essays, fantasy, and science fiction. My attempt to integrate creativity, psychology, philosophy, and spirituality imbues everything I write. You will find hundreds of related essays and articles on my blog. I live quietly in British Columbia's scenic Fraser Valley, a beautiful place in which to wax philosophical.

2 thoughts on “The Creative Eureka Experience”

  1. Does this link up with lateral thinking, I wonder? I’ve always liked Descartes because wasn’t he the one who recommended that people break an unjust law? Lol about boarding the bus for the mathematician, an advertisement for using public transport more there.

  2. Lucinda, your remark about lateral thinking gives me an idea for a future post! Many thanks. Lateral thinking is a conscious tactic for solving problems as opposed to the unconscious associative process which precedes the typical eureka moment. Instead of the direct logical approach, lateral thinking tries to be indirect and creative. The objective is to come up with more innovative solutions than those derived from simple analysis. You have spotted the link, though. Lateral thinking does attempt to tap into associative thinking by looking at problems from unusual angles.

Your thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: